By Eric M. Overholt, California Workers’ Compensation attorney since 2007 and member of the California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (CAAA) State Board of Directors and Amicus Committee
Last reviewed: October 27, 2026
Short answer: If your doctor asked for treatment and you got a letter saying it was “denied” or “modified,” that decision came from utilization review (UR), the insurer’s process for deciding whether treatment is medically necessary. In most cases, the only way to challenge it is independent medical review (IMR), and you generally have 30 days from service of the UR decision to file (just 10 days if the dispute is only about a drug on the state’s MTUS Drug List). Don’t wait: call your attorney the day the letter arrives.
Why I’m writing about this
When people picture a workers’ comp fight, they usually picture the insurance company denying the whole claim. In my practice, that’s the exception. When I looked back across our active workers’ comp files, only about 1 in 8 involved a denial of the entire claim. But roughly 45% had at least one utilization review denial of treatment, and about 40% went on to IMR.
In other words, the most common fight isn’t over whether you were hurt at work. It’s over what treatment you get for it. Physical therapy, acupuncture, injections, medications, MRIs, and surgery are the requests I see denied or cut back most often.
What is utilization review (UR)?
Every California employer, or its insurer or claims administrator, must have a utilization review program (Labor Code § 4610(g)). When your treating doctor sends a request for authorization, UR decides whether to approve, modify, or deny it based on the state’s Medical Treatment Utilization Schedule (MTUS) guidelines (DWC: Utilization review).
A few rules worth knowing:
- Only a doctor can say no. A claims adjuster can approve treatment, but only a licensed physician who is competent to evaluate the specific clinical issues can deny or modify it for medical necessity (Lab. Code § 4610(g)(3)(A)).
- There are deadlines. For most requests, UR must decide within 5 normal business days of receiving the request and the information it reasonably needs, and no later than 14 days from the doctor’s recommendation. If your health faces an imminent and serious threat, the limit is 72 hours (§ 4610(i)(1), (i)(3)). Weekends and holidays don’t count: the Appeals Board has held that a “working day” under section 4610 “means a day other than a Saturday, Sunday, or holiday as defined in the Government Code” (Pa’u v. Department of Forestry/Cal Fire (2019) 84 Cal.Comp.Cases 815 (significant panel decision), PDF p. 14).
- You must get it in writing. A denial or modification has to be sent to you in writing, generally within two business days of the decision for a prospective request, with a plain explanation of the reasons and the guidelines used (§ 4610(i)(4)–(5)). Sending it late counts against the insurer: “A UR decision that is timely made but is not timely communicated is untimely” (Bodam v. San Bernardino County/Dept. of Social Services (2014) 79 Cal.Comp.Cases 1519 (significant panel decision), PDF p. 2).
- A denial can stick for a year. A UR denial stays in effect for 12 months for the same treatment requested by the same doctor (or that doctor’s practice group), unless there is a documented change in the facts (§ 4610(k)).
How do I read a UR letter?
The question I hear most often from clients holding one of these letters is: “Do I sign this?” No. A UR letter is a notice, not something you sign and send back. What does need your signature, if you decide to challenge the decision, is the separate IMR application form that is supposed to be enclosed with it.
When you read the letter, look for:
- Which items were approved and which were denied or modified. Many letters are mixed. I’ve seen clients assume the whole request was denied when two of the three items were actually approved and simply never got scheduled.
- “Modified” means cut back. A modification can mean fewer therapy visits than your doctor asked for, or 30 days of a medication instead of 90.
- The reason. Sometimes UR says the doctor didn’t send enough information. That is often fixable with a new, better-documented request from your doctor.
- The date on the letter and the IMR deadline box on the enclosed application form.
What is independent medical review (IMR)?
IMR is the state’s process for resolving medical-necessity disputes. An independent review organization working on behalf of the Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC) has a physician look at your records and decide whether the denied treatment is medically necessary (DWC: Independent Medical Review; Lab. Code § 4610.6). In most cases, IMR is the only way to challenge a UR decision; you can’t simply ask a workers’ comp judge to overrule it (Lab. Code § 4610.5(e)).
Key points:
- The deadline. You must file within 30 days of service of the written UR decision, or within 10 days if the dispute is only about a drug on the MTUS Drug List (8 CCR § 9792.10.1(a); Lab. Code § 4610.5(h)). The current DWC IMR form explains that these deadlines are extended to 35 and 15 days when the form is mailed, or 40 and 20 days when mailed from outside California (DWC Form IMR, eff. 4/1/26). Don’t count on the extra days; file early.
- You don’t pay for it. The employer pays the cost of IMR (§ 4610.6(l); DWC IMR page).
- Your doctor can help. Your treating physician can join in and submit information supporting the request (§ 4610.5(j)).
- Timing. A standard IMR decision is due within 30 days of the review organization receiving the request and supporting documents, within 5 working days for formulary drug disputes, and within 3 days for certified urgent cases (§ 4610.6(d)).
- If IMR approves the treatment, the insurer must authorize it within five working days of receiving the decision (§ 4610.6(j)).
- The decision is binding. It can be appealed to the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board within 30 days, but only on narrow grounds such as fraud, conflict of interest, bias, or a plainly erroneous factual finding (§ 4610.6(g)–(h)). Two practical points from the Appeals Board:
- When the IMR decision is served by mail, the 30-day appeal period “is extended by five days” (Matute v. Los Angeles Unified School Dist. (2015) 80 Cal.Comp.Cases 1036 (Appeals Bd. en banc), PDF p. 2).
- The appeal must be verified. An unverified appeal “may be dismissed for lack of verification if the appealing party does not cure the defect within a reasonable time after receiving notice of the defect” (Torres v. Contra Costa Schools Ins. Group (2014) 79 Cal.Comp.Cases 1181 (significant panel decision), PDF p. 1).
What should I do after a UR denial? A step-by-step plan
- Note the date the day the letter arrives. Write the date on the envelope and keep it.
- Send a copy to your attorney immediately. Every UR and IMR letter. Don’t assume we already have it.
- Tell your doctor’s office what was approved. If part of the request was approved, ask them to schedule it now.
- Ask your doctor whether to resubmit. If the denial says information was missing, a new request with better documentation may be the fastest fix.
- File the IMR application on time, with a copy of the UR decision. If you have a lawyer, we usually handle this for you. You also must send a copy of the signed form to the claims administrator (8 CCR § 9792.10.1(b)).
- Keep a simple log of calls and letters with the adjuster: dates, names, and what was said.
- Talk to your lawyer before paying out of pocket. More on that below.
Real situations I see in my practice
These are composites drawn from many cases, with details changed so no one can be identified.
“The adjuster won’t call me back.” A worker with a back injury had a doctor’s recommendation for injections sitting for weeks. The calls to the adjuster went nowhere. When we dug in, we found the UR decision had gone out late. That matters. In a binding en banc decision, the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board held that a UR decision “is invalid and not subject to independent medical review (IMR) only if it is untimely,” and that timeliness disputes “must be resolved by the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB), not IMR.” As the Board put it, “An untimely UR decision is the same as no UR.” But the Board was also clear that this “does not mean that the treatment is automatically awarded.” Instead, the workers’ compensation judge decides whether the treatment is medically necessary “based on substantial medical evidence” (Dubon v. World Restoration, Inc. (2014) 79 Cal.Comp.Cases 1298, 1299 (Appeals Bd. en banc), PDF pp. 1–2, 15–16). So a late denial opens the door to the judge, but you still need solid medical reporting from your doctor. In cases like that, filing for a hearing is often what finally gets treatment moving.
The family that paid for the MRI. In another case, a family grew so frustrated waiting for imaging approval that they paid for an MRI themselves. I understand the impulse. But under the law, neither you nor the employer is liable for treatment that UR denied unless IMR overturns that denial (§ 4610.5(e)). If IMR later finds the treatment necessary, the insurer must reimburse within 20 days (§ 4610.6(j)). Reimbursement is not guaranteed, so call us first.
The half-approved letter. A client called upset that her physical therapy had been “denied.” Reading the letter together, we saw that UR had approved some visits and cut back the rest. She had lost weeks of care she was already entitled to. We got the approved visits scheduled and challenged the rest through IMR.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to sign the UR letter?
No. The UR letter is a notice. If you want to challenge the denial, you (or your attorney) sign and file the separate IMR application that should come with it (DWC IMR page).
What is the deadline to request IMR in California?
30 days from service of the written UR decision, or 10 days if the dispute is only about an MTUS Drug List medication (8 CCR § 9792.10.1). If the insurer didn’t include the required information with the decision, the clock may not start until it does (§ 9792.10.1(e)(2)).
Who pays for IMR?
Your employer or its insurer, not you (Lab. Code § 4610.6(l)).
Can a nurse or adjuster deny my treatment?
They can approve it, but a denial or modification based on medical necessity must come from a licensed physician competent to evaluate the clinical issues (Lab. Code § 4610(g)(3)(A)).
Can I appeal directly to the insurer instead of filing IMR?
Some insurers offer a voluntary internal UR appeal, which must be requested within 10 days of receiving the UR decision (8 CCR § 9792.10.1(f)). It’s optional; don’t let it distract you from the IMR deadline.
What if the insurer is denying my whole claim, not just treatment?
When the insurer disputes liability for reasons other than medical necessity, the IMR clock doesn’t start until it serves notice that the liability dispute is resolved (Lab. Code § 4610.5(h)(2)). Those disputes go through a different path, often a QME and a hearing.
Talk to us about a treatment denial
If you’ve received a UR denial or aren’t sure what a letter means, call Overholt & Cremeans, APC at 619-673-8387.
Eric M. Overholt is a California workers’ compensation attorney who represents injured workers. Read his full bio.
Last reviewed: October 27, 2026
This post is general information, not legal advice, and past results don’t guarantee future outcomes.

